I hope that Riddle of Berlin becomes a useful means for readers to enjoy a fast-paced, page turning thriller as they also contemplate the emotional experience of the characters. I enjoy developing my thoughts about books in discussions with friends in book club format (my little group we call the Philosophers Club) and others wherever they occur and invite me to do my thing.
Based on my experience in presenting Riddle of Berlin to book clubs, which I thoroughly enjoy doing, I thought it might be useful to list here the questions and discussion points that I have found to be of interest, both of my own thought as well as the readers who have been kind enough to share their thoughts with me.
a. Why did Jaëgerman jump into the Seine?
i. Have you ever experienced these emotions?
ii. Have you ever wanted to jump?
b. Why did Carmen save the almost dead meat in the cold waters of the Seine?
i. Have you ever saved someone?
ii. How did it make you feel?
iii. Have you ever let someone suffer, not being brave enough to step forward and take the risk of intruding into something that is none of your business?
iv. How did you feel about that?
c. Why did the Lion create so much chaos?
i. Do you know a Lion?
ii. Would you stop them?
d Do you like Lucy Anton?
i. If someone set out to destroy you, maybe steal your identity, what would you do?
ii. If someone made a sex video imposing your face on someone else’s body, would you do what Dr. Lucy did?
iii. Dr. Lucy is a strong woman. How do you feel about such a character in a thriller?
e. Moriah Jaëgerman is another strong woman.
i. Have you had a mud pit experience in your life?
ii. If so, what did you learn about your father?
iii. Your mother?
iv. Your siblings?
v. Did it help you later in life?
vi. Have you had an Orange Girl experience?
vii. Have you been tortured?
viii. Did you survive as a better or worse person?
f. What was Mark Anton seduced by?
g. Was Carmen an angel?
i. What you imagine that a real angel would do if she saw Jaëgerman floating in the water?
ii. If you were Jaëgerman and awoke in arms as he did, after having jumped intending to end your life, what you think upon hearing her voice, feeling her touch, and looking up at her face as consciousness took hold inside of you?
iii. Are angels warm and soft?
iv. What do you think an angel would be like if she held you?
h. Would a sane person risk her life for a corpse in the water?
i. Would you vote for Lucius Alcorn?
i. Why is he the most popular politician in the world?
j. Would you try to bring in Orinth Hemme as Daidre Patton did?
i. What was her motivation?
ii. Do you believe in anything that strongly?
iii. Would you sacrifice your life for that?
k. Why did Jaëgerman decline the Congressional Medal of Honor?
i. Was he correct in his action?
ii. What would you have done?
l. What should Lucius Alcorn have done when he learned of the Riddle of Berlin?
m. Would you intervene in the criminal proceedings of a teacher who took an interest in you as a youth and helped mold you to experience your future?
n. Why did Jaëgerman invite Lucius Alcorn to the remote mountaintop in the Czech Republic?
i. Should Alcorn have proceeded without security?
ii. If Vice President Alcorn had asked you about the trip, what would you have advised him?
o. What you have done if you had been Nell when advised of your spouse’s death?
i. When you learned that your spouse was alive and were asked to come to Europe?
ii. When you saw your spouse’s disfigured appearance?
(a) Would you love your spouse then?
iii. When your spouse advised of love for another?
(a) Would you love your spouse then?
iv. What would you have said to your spouse after saving you and Moriah in Paris?
(a) Would you love him then?
p. Can you imagine what Del felt at the Place de Pyramides in Paris when Moriah emerged from the van and recognized you?
i. What Moriah felt?
ii. What Nell felt?
iii. What Lucius Alcorn felt?
q. If you were Jaëgerman’s daughter, what would you have said to him when you met in Paris?
r. If you were Nell, what you have said to your husband in Paris?
s. Can you imagine what Jaëgerman (Del) must have felt when the Congressional Medal of Honor was awarded to his daughter post- mortem?
t. If you were Del, and the choice to make that he did between returning to life with Nell and Moriah, or meeting Carmen and making a new life in Slovakia (having officially been declared dead), or talking some other path, what would you do?
u. Do you like the combination of thriller context and emotions of real people?
i. Did Riddle of Berlin work for you?
ii. Would you like to read the sequel – 30,000 Camels?
4 What is the Role of Religion in Riddle of Berlin?
How do you feel about the following comments about the religious learning to be found in Riddle of Berlin?[1]
a. Two Lost Souls
Jaëgerman felt an inner shame – lost touch with his wife – he perceived something supernatural (sirens in the river) luring him to his death.
Note: What is the real reason Jaëgerman wants to commit suicide? Is he looking for idyllic love? Is he looking for purpose? What is causing his depression? What happened that was so traumatic that it caused a loss of memory?
Carmen was the victim of an abusive husband – felt in her soul she would find happiness with a better man.
b. Death and Resurrection
Jaëgerman tries to commit suicide by drowning and is found by Carmen on the brink of death – a bloated body; a grotesque shape barely recognizable as a person. “The chalky pallor of death emanated from the body.” No clear pulse – no discernable heartbeat.
c. Salvation and The Good Samaritan
Carmen extracts him from the water and with great effort painstakingly bring shim back to life, and restores his strength. She literally uses her own body as a blanket to warm his body.
d. Immediate and Unconditional Love from the “Angel”
Carmen sits with him night and day, praying that he would awaken; looking for a sign of life; ministering to him; not noticing smells of infection; expressing her love in songs to this grotesque unconscious man she has never met.
e. Answered Prayer
When Jaëgerman finally awakens, Carmen thanks Jesus for bringing her man home to her. Carmen says “I have been waiting for you. Now you have come.”
f. Visions of Heaven
Jaëgerman thinks that he has died and gone to heaven. “Jesus, am I home?” is the first thing he says.
Even later, Jaëgerman, “still assumed he was on a journey to heaven, escorted by his own personal angel.”
g. Rebirth
After Jaëgerman woke, the souls of Jaëgerman and Carmen met for the first time. “The man was reborn in the natural environment of warm water and human, motherly touch.”
h. Inner Peace
After Jaëgerman awoke with Carmen ministered to him “peace was in his eyes.”
i. Realization of the Reality of the Supernatural (Prophesy)
The reason there was peace in his eyes was that Jaëgerman realized that, “This Angel, this siren who appeared only in his dreams, was real. Carmen’s dream had become a reality.”
Jaëgerman ultimately determines that the salvation, the peace, the love that he was expecting to find after death has actually come to him as the result of his near death experience through the pure, totally trusting and unconditional love of a good and beautiful woman.
His Angel and his savior is a real flesh and blood woman, although their coming together was preordained, reconceived and orchestrated by spiritual and supernatural means.
j. Continuing unconditional love and guardianship from the Angel
Carmen willingly satisfies all of Jaëgerman’s sexual desires, and he satisfies hers. He says, “Angels are warm and delicious. She is swept along in a “channel of ecstasy.”
Carmen supplies Jaëgerman with a new name and a new identity.
Carmen comforts Jaëgerman (“Del”) when he has nightmares in his sleep, “curling up as a baby in the womb, held securely by Carmen.”
Carmen fees and pampers Jaëgerman during his recuperation, while still working full time every day. Del continues to call her an Angel from God. She calls him her deliverer. They are madly in love without even speaking the same language.
When Del asks Carmen to leave the ship to take Mark to live with her parents in Slovakia, she immediately agrees without asking why or how it would be paid for, knowing only that it would be dangerous for her people. She left immediately, even though she and Mark had to swim at a frantic pace to avoid drowning in the cold water. She intuitively knew that this was all necessary and implicitly trusted Del.
When Del was thrown on the bank of the Danube from the explosion that sunk his ship, it was Carmen who somehow found him because she had been following the ship on a bicycle to watch over him. After plowing three dead bodies to find him, she single handedly lugged him home to Slovakia covered in dung and straw before collapsing with exhaustion. When Del awoke form unconsciousness and rasped like a baby searching for his mother, she jumped from a deep sleep and ran to his side and soothed him in Slovakian.
[1] These comments were made by my friend Robert Thornton, a prominent litigator in Dallas, as part of our Philosopher Club discussion of the manuscript in February 2008.